Saturday, November 21, 2026

On Being a Matthew 25 Christian: A Homily for the Reign of Christ

 Preached at All Saints, Collingwood, Anglican Diocese of Toronto, on the Feast of the Reign of Christ, 22 November, 2026.  Texts for this Sunday: Ezekiel 34: 11-16, 20-24; Psalm100; Ephesians 1:15-23; Matthew 25:31-46  

 All the nations will be gathered before him, and he will separate people one from another as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats (Mt 25:32)



You may have noticed an unpleasant odour at the end of today’s gospel, and I don’t mean the cologne of the guy in the next pew.  It was a whiff of sulfur and brimstone, mixed in with Jesus’ words that those he judges as uncharitable and unkind “will go away into punishment” (Mt 25:46).


You may have caught that unpleasant scent last Sunday as well, for at the end of the parable of the talents, the servant who hid the talent given to him is “[thrown] into the outer darkness, where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth” (Mt 25.30).  And the previous Sunday, in the parable of the bridesmaids, the ones who did not have oil in their lamps and who were found unready were shut out of the banquet hall.


So today, as we come to the end of Matthew’s gospel, with Jesus giving his last teachings before his arrest, and his having predicted the destruction of Jerusalem, we are getting the distinct sense that the prince of peace, the loving shepherd can also be a stern judge, one who will decide our fate when he comes to take his place “on the throne of glory” (Mt 25.46).


Today are theme as we finish up our Joyful Giving campaign is outreach and later Penny is going to talk about our food ministry.   That ministry in its many forms is important to us, our volunteers take pleasure in their work, and I know our guests, the people we feed, appreciate what we do.   So today is a very good day to hear Jesus’ words that our duty and our calling as his followers is to feed people (Mt 25.35).   Check.  We get that.  All good.


But, what about that last bit, that unpleasant hint of sulfur mixed in with the good smells coming from the kitchen?  What do we do with that?   A wise professor of mine at seminary said that if there is a verse that if there’s a scripture reading that’s going to trouble the congregation, and the preacher doesn’t say anything helpful, then the preacher is at fault.   The gospel is supposed to be good news.   So I hope to make some comments that are helpful.


First, if you’re worried about being a sheep or a goat, then stop it.   You’re fine.   You’re all here because you heard the shepherd’s call.  Some of us might hear that call more faintly than others, but we’re all in the right place, and if anyone’s missing, you know the shepherd is going to go look for them, because that’s what shepherds do.   So don’t worry.   As I’ve said before, if your religion is scary and if your god is frightening, then you’ve got the wrong religion and a bad god.


What does Jesus want us to do?   He couldn’t be plainer.   Feed the hungry.   Tend the sick.  Visit the lonely.   Give clothes to those without.   Jesus spells out in simple terms what he means by “love thy neighbour”.   There’s no mystery to it.  It’s remarkable that during the American midterm elections, the term “Matthew 25 Christians” came to stand for so-called progressive Christians who believed that this gospel passage was a call to political action.    Many American Christians on the right disagreed that Matthew 25 was a call to action.   But one thing, I think, is clear.  Jesus call to care for “the least of these who are members of my family” cannot be ignored.


One thing I would point out about today’s gospel is how generous it actually is.    Jesus describes a time of judgement that will involve everyone.   “All the nations will be gathered”, he says.   In Greek, the word for nations is ethnoi, which in the New Testament is the word for foreigners, gentiles, non-Jews, everyone.   So Jesus envisions a time when all the world will be gathered, every nation from everywhere on earth, and the judgement will be very simple.   How did you treat the less fortunate?   How did you care for them?  How did you show love and sympathy?


Note what Jesus doesn’t say.  He doesn’t say that people will be judged on their intellectual or theological beliefs.   He doesn’t say that they must accept him, Jesus, as their personal saviour.   He doesn’t say that they must be of a particular faith, or, for that matter, of any faith.  He simply says, what did you do to help others?  Belief is measured by compassion, not by adherence to any creed.   And so I think this gospel reminds us to look generously on those who are not churchgoers, not Anglicans, not Chrisitans, and to see that all peoples of all or no beliefs can find favour with Jesus is their core belief is compassion.


So who is a goat?   Not for me to say, but I will say that there is a trend in society, advocated by the super-rich and the tech billionaires,  to denounce charity and to cast doubt on the value of empathy.    Last year the world’s richest man took pleasure in saying that he fed the US International Aid Agency “into the wood chipper” and the only thing that he regretted about that action was that he had missed some good parties.  Sounds like the bleating of a goat to me, but we have to believe that sincere penitence and God’s grace can turn goats into sheep.  But I would also say that the fire and brimstone stuff in the gospels is to catch our attention and say that our actions always have consequences, and that those who choose to make life a hell for others, are also choosing it for themselves.


So while there is a trend of some in society to celebrate unbridled wealth and greed, I think that most people choose the side of decency and compassion.  I have faith in the goodness of people and I think Jesus call of caring in today’s gospel has wide appeal, including many that we will never see in these pews, and that’s ok.   So, dear saints, don’t worry your wooly little heads, we are all sheep and our shepherd is good.   And the only smells we should notice are the good smells coming from our church kitchen as we do out part to feed those who are Jesus’ family.

No comments:

Mad Padre

Mad Padre
Opinions expressed within are in no way the responsibility of anyone's employers or facilitating agencies and should by rights be taken as nothing more than one person's notional musings, attempted witticisms, and prayerful posturings.

Followers

Blog Archive

Labels